In direction of A Higher Lecturers’ Efficiency Administration in Nigeria: The Steadiness Scorecard Method

In direction of A Higher Lecturers’ Efficiency Administration in Nigeria: The Steadiness Scorecard Method

In direction of A Higher Lecturers’ Efficiency Administration in Nigeria: The Steadiness Scorecard Method


Schooling is sacrosanct to nationwide improvement. Schooling and nationwide improvement are the 2 sides of a coin that mutually reinforce and problem one another. Jega [1997] affirmed, “Schooling is usually thought to be a essential and important requirement for nationwide improvement. It’s central to socioeconomic and technological development, and it’s essential to self-sustaining and self-generating means of constructive transformation of recent society.”

The federal government appreciates the importance of training to nationwide improvement and can marshal its assets to realize its avowed objective of a reinvigorated public service. Odumosu [2004] stated, “Schooling in Nigeria is … an enormous authorities enterprise that has witnessed evolution of presidency full and dynamic intervention and energetic participation. The Federal Authorities has adopted training as an instrument per excellence for efficient nationwide improvement.”

It’s antithetical that service supply within the training sector is unattractive regardless of its strategic function in efficient nationwide improvement. It’s palpable that the sector is a not-for-profit public enterprise. There may be, nevertheless, a basic consensus amongst stakeholders starting from authorities supervisory companies, practitioners, dad and mom and the press to learners that the usual of training falls far beneath expectations.

Who’s a Instructor?

Achimugu [2000] said that Nigerian Lecturers Union NUT (1994) defines a trainer “as an individual who has the registrable skilled qualification, which permits him to be appointed to show at any acceptable degree of acknowledged training in any nation and who’s of sound thoughts and who’s mentally alert.”

The World Ebook Encyclopedia [1985] expanded the scope to incorporate “these of a college counselor, college psychologist, basic supervisor or supervisor of a topic space, studying specialist, coordinator of steering, college principal, director of vocational training, trainer of handicapped youngsters, superintendent of faculties, director of instruction, dean of scholars, school administrator, or trainer in an indication college.”

In Search of A Higher Efficiency Administration System

The historically appraisal technique of analysis that polarize the efficiency of lecturers between qualitative and quantitative indices is an annual or biennial ritual within the college system immediately. Sadly, it has turn into a routine. It’s ineffectual due to the prevalence of lecturers’ suboptimal efficiency and poor service supply. The tactic is topic to abuse by supervising officers who disregard meritocracy for the ‘Nigerian Issue’ variables equivalent to nepotism, size of service and godfather syndrome to adjudge lecturers’ efficiency and promote the fortunate few regardless of evident gaps in output and absence of whole high quality administration.

The most important drawback coverage makers and directors face apart getting lecturers with requisite high quality is that of guaranteeing high quality service from these lecturers. The advice of Afe [2001] that “When well-qualified persons are recruited into instructing, excessive requirements are ensured” can’t obtain this goal. The efficiency of those certified and productive lecturers won’t be measured and sustained if the system of efficiency administration is flawed.

Idea of Balanced Scorecard

Kaplan and Norton [1992] developed Balanced Scorecard [BSC] in 1992 at Harvard Enterprise Faculty in United States of America. The Balanced Scorecard is a strategic administration system that allows establishments to spell out their imaginative and prescient and technique, and rework them in actions able to attaining its mission. It’s essentially used to find out organizational efficiency utilizing monetary and non-financial measurement in 4 views: monetary, buyer, inside course of, and studying and development.

Kaplan & Norton [2002] stated,

“We created the Balanced Scorecard as a result of monetary measurements had turn into inadequate for modern organizations. Methods for creating worth had shifted from managing tangible property to knowledge-based methods that created and deployed a company’s intangible property, together with buyer relationships; modern services and products; high-quality and responsive working processes; expertise and data of the workforce; the data know-how that helps the workforce and hyperlinks the agency to its prospects and suppliers; and the organizational local weather that encourages innovation, problem-solving, and enchancment.”

The Balanced Scorecard is a efficiency administration strategy that’s versatile and adaptable to suit any dimension establishment. It aligns imaginative and prescient and mission with stakeholders’ expectations and the day-to-day actions of the establishment, manages and evaluates technique and guides operation effectivity plans. It additionally assists to develop group capability. The scorecard permits the establishment to measure monetary and buyer outcomes, operations, and group capability as proven in Determine 1 beneath:

Determine 1: Balanced Scorecard Hyperlinks Efficiency Measures [Source: Kaplan S. R. & Norton P. D. [1992] The Balanced Scorecard – Measures that Drive
Efficiency, Harvard Enterprise Assessment Journal – January-February 1992 Version, Boston, Massachusetts]

Determine 2: Howard Rohm’s Design of Balanced Scorecard Efficiency System [Source: Performance Management in Action – A Balancing Act. Perform Volume 2, Issue 2]

Balanced Scorecard in Schooling

The Balanced Scorecard takes into cognizance that mission is the important thing driver of the efficiency of establishments within the public sector. In utility to the training sector, subsequently, the scorecard framework will change from revenue making in Determine 2 to mirror its mission-driven nature said in Determine 3. The Federal School of Schooling [Technical] Akoka as a not-for-profit establishment has a mission to coach high quality lecturers that might in flip educate learners in decrease ranges of the training sector, and empower entrepreneurs to determine micro companies to spice up the financial system of the nation. Balanced Scorecard will entrench methods to measure the efficiency of lecturers within the School to find out their operational efficiencies in curriculum implementation and classroom instructing in the direction of the actualizing of its mission.

Determine 3: Design of Schooling Sector Balanced Scorecard [An adaptation from Howard Rohm design of public sector balanced scorecard]

There’s a paradigm shift of emphasis within the focus and positions of the views of the fundamental design of the general public sector scorecard system in Determine 3 in distinction to the generic Balanced Scorecard efficiency system in Determine 2 due to the emphasis on Mission within the former. Workers & Institutional Capability in Determine 3 substitutes Studying & Development in Determine 2 to underscore the relative significance of lecturers as a number one component to synchronizes different elements for attaining institutional mission. Once more, funds in Determine 3 is most popular to monetary perspective in Determine 2 due to the significance of funds formulation and execution processes within the administration of presidency funds.

Balanced Scorecard Advantages to Schooling

1. The Balanced Scorecard invents the idea of steady studying in efficiency administration system of the establishments. It aligns all of the employees to technique in a single framework and eliminates multiplicity of technique institution-wide implementation. It includes the collection of metrics for the measurement processes, collection of initiatives, cohesively mould these initiatives right into a single platform for strategic deployment and Spartan allocation of assets to eradicate waste.

2. It entrenches strategic planning as a lifestyle moderately than as a handy different. It helps to construct a rational budgeting system in a tightly regulated financial system with finite nationwide monetary assets. It ties useful resource allocations to efficiency and replaces reliance on instinct in resolution making to a scientific fact-based government decision-making. It forecasts future consequence by producing cause-effect predictions and creating situations.

3. It assists to enhance the establishment’s services, notion and score of lecturers within the thoughts of the stakeholders in addition to raises visibility of lecturers’ actions in implementing authorities’s reform programmes, services suggestions and entrench a tradition of public accountability.

4. It permits establishments to benchmark finest practices by way of lecturers’ efficiency and output of service supply through the use of efficiency measurement knowledge collected as a foundation of comparability with international knowledge assets.

5. It alleviates the funding burden on authorities. Schooling just isn’t solely a expensive enterprise but in addition an financial enterprise with out fast return. Balanced Scorecard will make clear the budgetary objectives of the establishment and speed up its budgeted financial returns. As Faculties of Schooling positive factors funding autonomy, the scorecard will entrench a tradition of budgetary prudence and financial self-discipline.

Constructing & Implementing A Balanced Scorecard

This paper proposes a seven-step framework for the implementation of balanced scorecard for measuring lecturers’ efficiency within the training sector in Nigeria.

1. Choose Balanced Scorecard Workforce

A staff must be chosen and charged with a accountability to design and implement the steadiness scorecard. The staff will consider the establishment’s mission, core beliefs, public expectations, budgetary place, short- and long-term objectives and description worth creation parameters for stakeholders. It ought to receive useful resource necessities to develop and maintain the scorecard, and develop a rollout communications plan for lecturers’ buy-in and resultant assist for the modifications from stakeholders. This communications plan will contain inside and exterior public data actions to teach lecturers and stakeholders in regards to the Balanced Scorecard initiative and the way it works.

2. Make clear Institutional Technique & Goals

The establishment will design quite a few overarching themes that might be crafted into particular institutional methods. Examples might be to Enhance Instructor Schooling, Improve High quality of Instructing Supplies or Create a New Enterprise. Sure degree of inventive considering from the rank and file of lecturers is required with a view to obtain outcomes at this stage. The staff ought to collation of those themes. Within the course of, it shouldn’t impose any premeditated themes on the method. It will eradicate hidden agenda from any curiosity group and permit for efficient collection of particular methods for adoption.

The following degree is to separate the chosen institutional technique smaller elements is named goals. The goals are the fundamental constructing blocks of technique, that’s the elements that make up full methods. On this occasion, the technique of a central theme of Enhance Instructor Schooling or Create a New Enterprise might have such goals as Deploy efficient instructing methodology and conventional self-discipline, Elevated Instructor trainers experience, expertise and talents, Improved Know-how Capability or Efficient and Efficient and Environment friendly Company Governance, Improved Service Worth, Cut back Reliance on Authorities Allocation amongst others.

3. Design Strategic Map

The staff, at this stage, will construct a strategic map for the establishment’s total enterprise technique. This map is the mechanism that reveals how an goal [effect] depends on one other goal [cause], and the way, taken collectively, they type a strategic thread from actions to desired finish outcomes. It normally will use the cause-effect linkages [i.e. if-the logic connections]. Thereafter, the elements [objectives] of technique are linked and positioned in acceptable scorecard perspective classes. The connection amongst technique elements is used to determine the important thing efficiency drivers of every technique that, taken collectively, chart the trail to profitable consequence as might be perceived by the eyes of shoppers and stakeholders.

4. Develop Efficiency Measures

The staff will develop efficiency measures to trace each strategic and operational progress. On the stage, the specified outcomes and the processes which can be used to supply these outcomes are clearly spelt out. Desired outcomes are measured from the angle of inside and exterior outcomes, and processes are measured from the angle of the method house owners and the actions wanted to satisfy buyer necessities. Relationships among the many anticipated outcomes and the method wanted to get the outcomes must be totally understood earlier than the staff can assign significant efficiency measures. Particularly, the Strategic Map must be used to develop significant efficiency measures for every goal.

5. Champion New Initiatives

The staff will now determine new initiatives which can be wanted for implementation to make sure that the brand new methods advanced are profitable within the establishment. The point of interest of Steps 1 to 4 is that it’s going to lead the staff to evolve new initiatives. These new initiatives developed on the finish of the scorecard constructing course of are extra strategic than if they’re developed within the summary.

6. Implementation

This stage includes the implementation of the brand new initiatives developed by the balanced scorecard by transmitting the main points of implementation milestones and duties all through the establishment to the varied colleges and departments, and in the end to lecturers, non-academic employees and college students. The company scorecard might be translated into the varied colleges and departments scorecards which can be aligned with the institutional technique. The staff ought to word that the best approach of obtain that is to start out with the goals and measures from the institution-wide technique map, and develop supporting goals [and measures] for the varied colleges and division, lecturers, non-academic employees and college students.

7. Publish Implementation Assessment
At this stage, the Balanced Scorecard positive factors benefit over different conventional strategies of appraisal as a result of it permits of the inbuilt mechanism of post-implementation auto-evaluation. The success of the institutional methods adopted is reviewed to find out whether or not the anticipated outcomes have been attained. The staff might want to align the general technique of the establishment [that is, the mission] to make sure that there isn’t any deviation. Suggestions mechanism is created to check the technique assumptions to find out their effectiveness. This suggestions is analyzed and public expectations are factored into the evaluation for efficient assessment.


The next suggestions are provided to the Federal Ministry of Schooling to think about Balanced Scorecard strategy for attaining higher lecturers’ efficiency administration within the training sector in Nigeria.

1. Balanced Scorecard must be adopted as a efficiency administration system for lecturers and directors within the college system. The scorecard just isn’t costly to implement as a result of it will probably construct on current appraisal strategies and synchronize strategies right into a single platform of efficiency administration.

2. A nationwide central working committee comprising of staff of seasoned professionals drawn from the academia and Organized Personal Sector must be set as much as advance the research of Steadiness Scorecard past the precursory template of this paper and conduct in depth analysis with the target of designing a nationwide strategic map for the completely different ranges of academic establishments in Nigeria from the Universities, Polytechnics, Faculties of Schooling. Competent and resourceful professionals must be appointed into the varied scorecard groups on the nationwide and native ranges.

3. A phased introduction and implementation of Balanced Scorecard over a interval of twelve to twenty-four is advocated. It will enable for efficient orientation and dissemination of the communications plans to hold alongside all stakeholders. Change administration might be efficient to eradicate resistance and sabotage of the scorecard might be taken care of with this technique.

4. Authorities ought to have the nationwide will to approve the adoption of Balanced Scorecard and make satisfactory funds and assets like know-how, and literature obtainable for its profitable implementation.

5. There must be data change programme by using useful resource neighborhood on the native and worldwide degree. This exercise will deepen the data and competence of the native and nationwide groups which can be empowered to facilitate the introduction and implementation of the scorecard.


Achimugu, L. [2000], The agonies of nigerian lecturers: nut – pal or foe.
Kano: Baron Press Restricted

Afe, J.O. (2001), Reflections on turning into a trainer and: challenges of
trainer training. College of Benin: Inaugural Lecture Sequence 64

Aghenta, J.A. (1991) Instructor effectiveness within the nigerian academic
system. Edited by B.C. Emenogu, O.V.N. Okoro et al Onitsha, Orient Publishers Ltd.

Berkman, Eric [2002] Methods to use the balanced scorecard, CIO Journal Subject of
Might 15, 2002. Worldwide Knowledge Group Firm

Federal Republic of Nigeria (1998). Nationwide coverage on training. Lagos,

Jega, A.M. (1997): The state and training in Nigeria immediately, paper introduced at
the “Kano Week ’97, organized by the Kano State College students’ Affiliation,
Usmanu Danfodiyo College, Sokoto, September 15.

Kaplan S. R. & Norton P. D. [1992] The balanced scorecard – measures that
drive efficiency, Harvard Enterprise Assessment Journal – January-February
1992 Version, Boston, Massachusetts: Harvard Enterprise Faculty Press

Kaplan S. R. & Norton P. D. [1996] The balanced scorecard: translating
technique into motion, Boston, Massachusetts: Harvard Enterprise Faculty Press

Kaplan S. R. & Norton P. D. [2001] The strategy-focused group: how
balanced scorecard firms thrive within the new enterprise
surroundings, Boston, Massachusetts: Harvard Enterprise Faculty Press

Kaplan S. R. & Norton P. D. [2002] Partnering: the brand new face of management,

Odumosu, A. I. O. [2004] Primary ideas of training and strategies of
instructing. Ibadan: Olu-Akin Publishers

#Lecturers #Efficiency #Administration #Nigeria #Steadiness #Scorecard #Method

ministry of training

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top button